UNC Women’s Soccer has won 23 of 43 National Championships

Read Time: 3 minutes.

Let me set the scene.

I stepped on stage in front of 350 business owners.
I was delivering the keynote conversation on Day 2.

I say conversation instead of talk because I like to have a back-and-forth with the audience. No one likes to be talked at.

The topic for our conversation:

Mistakes I Made Learning How To Lead a High-Performing Team

As business owners, everyone in that room had employees. They were undoubtedly managers by design. And many were leaders by mindset.

I started that conversation with a statistic that our readers will be familiar with:

60%

"This statistic applies to everyone in this room. Anyone care to guess?"

It took a few beats for everyone to realize I genuinely wanted a response, so I let the silence work for me.

  • "% of useless meetings" (probably, but no)

  • "% of employees I'd like to fire." (dark. and no)

  • "% of us who wish we had a day job." (colder)

But this last one made me pause. It got a strong mix of groans and laughs from the crowd.

This was a room of people who had won. They had businesses large enough to be invited. They believed spending 3 days with other successful business owner was worth their time.

Would they really want to work for someone else?

So I revealed that the 60% number was the number of managers who failed in 18 months. I shared that it had been confirmed in multiple studies by reputable companies. And then I hit them with the knockout blow: One of the studies that confirmed this statistic focused exclusively on CEOs.

Jab. Jab. Hook!

But I was still stuck on that comment about wishing someone else was in charge. And since we we're now talking, I decided to practice what I preach: I got curious.

"By a show of hands, how many of you are willing to do what it takes to lead a high-performing team?"

I expected 95% of hands to shoot straight up.
Instead, I got a reluctant 25%.

Uh oh.

I've got 58 more minutes to talk about the virtue of building something the majority of this room doesn't want.

I honestly appreciated their candor and self-awareness. It is much easier to win when you know what game you're playing.

And saying you want to lead a high-performing team is an idea that's easy to agree with intellectually but hard to commit to in reality.

Here are 8 questions I use with CEOs I coach to test for the truth:

Are you willing to set and enforce a high bar—even when it makes you unpopular?

High standards aren't about perfection—they're about progression. The moment you accept mediocrity is the moment you guarantee it.

Your team is watching. They notice:

  • Which results you celebrate

  • Which behaviors you endorse

  • Which compromises you broker

Most importantly, they notice what you ignore. Because what you quietly tolerate becomes case law for your culture.

Can you let go of control and truly empower others?

Control is a virtuous lie we tell ourselves. And the tighter we squeeze, the more our team shrinks.

True empowerment means:

  • Letting them fail safely and learn deeply

  • Accepting that their way might be better than yours

  • Trading perfect execution for long-term compounding opportunities

Your expertise and execution got you here. Your ability to inspire and empower others will determine where you go next.

Are you ready to be the emotional shock absorber for your team?

Pressure flows downhill unless someone stops it. That someone is you.

Being an emotional shock absorber means:

  • Translating pressure into purpose

  • Absorbing stress without amplifying it

  • Maintaining clarity when others can't see straight

Your team needs you steady when everything else isn't.

Will you put systems ahead of individual heroics?

Heroes win battles. Systems win wars.

Great systems:

  • Make good behavior automatic

  • Turn best practices into daily practices

  • Scale excellence beyond individual effort

Individual brilliance is seductive. But sustainable excellence comes from systems that work when you're not there.

Do you crave growth, even when it's uncomfortable?

The best leaders are the best learners. They know that comfort and growth rarely coexist.

Growth requires:

  • Challenging your strongest beliefs

  • Modeling the vulnerability you want to see

  • Seeking feedback, especially when it hurts

Your personal comfort zone becomes your team's upper growth limit.

Can you make the hard calls, even when they're unpopular?

Easy choices make weak leaders.

Making hard calls requires:

  • Acting on data, not just instinct

  • Moving forward despite uncertainty

  • Owning the consequences, good or bad

Delayed decisions don't get easier—they just get more expensive.

Will you consistently invest in coaching and developing your team?

Great teams aren't found. They're built, one conversation at a time.

Real development means:

  • Investing time even when you don't have it

  • Trading quick fixes for lasting growth

  • Seeing potential others miss

Your return on investment in people compounds over time.

Can you stay patient when things aren't working—without lowering your standards?

Building excellence takes time. Lowering standards offers temporary relief but permanent regret.

Staying patient means:

  • Supporting effort while demanding results

  • Maintaining faith when progress isn't visible

  • Knowing when to pivot versus when to persist

Great leaders don't lower the bar. They build the ladder.

*****

Nothing says you have to lead a high-performing team. There are plenty of example of highly successful companies and teams that don’t operate this way.

The key to winning is knowing exactly what game you’re playing.
And adjusting your system to that reality.

What You Missed This Week

Did you miss this week’s MGMT Minute?

📌 We focused on handling high performers who are tough to work with.

And here are our most popular posts last week:

Our goal is to build a community of 1 million thoughtful, curious leaders.

Your ♻️ reposts on any or all of the above are always appreciated.

Thank you for reading. Appreciate you!

Dave & Mar

Ways To Work With Me

1:1 Executive Coaching - I’ve decided to take on two more CEOs this year. The cost is $6,000/month (6 month minimum). Includes 2 one-hour calls each month and ad hoc support between sessions. I’m meeting with executives this week. Please only grab time if you’re serious about leveling up this year.

MGMT Fundamentals - Join our next sprint. April 8 - 18, 12:00 pm -1:00 pm ET. Perfect for managers with 0-3 years of experience who want to quickly build the skills and systems to lead their team effectively from Day 1. Enroll today!

Customized Leadership Programs - Bring our MGMT Accelerator or MGMT Fundamentals in-house for a tailored, intensive workshop. Ideal for 15+ leaders.

Speaking - We’re now booking keynotes for Summer 2025. Hit reply on this note, and we can set up a time to discuss topics and pricing.

MGMT Playbook - If you’re here because someone forwarded this email, please subscribe before you leave.

.

Keep Reading