How High-Stakes Negotiators Use Emotional Intelligence to Win

Read Time: 4 minutes.

Most advice about emotional intelligence misses the point.

It's not about:

• Being nice.

• Reading the room.

• Having natural people skills.

EQ isn’t a soft skill.

EQ is a weapon.

Just ask any FBI hostage negotiator, professional poker player, or elite athlete. They've turned emotional intelligence into their strategic advantage.

I was re-reading “Never Split the Difference” by Chris Voss (former FBI lead negotiator) and something clicked:

The best leaders don't just possess EQ. They deploy it systematically to influence outcomes.

The same tactics that work in high-stakes negotiations can transform how you:

• Get better results from your team

• Navigate difficult conversations

• Build lasting influence

Here are 5 tips you can start using today.

Mirroring Your Speaker

What it is: Reiterating someone’s point using the same language they used.

Why it works: This makes people feel heard, encourages them to elaborate, and forces you to listen with intent.

How to use it with your team:

• Employee: “I just don’t think this project is going to work.”

• You: “This project isn’t going to work?” (pause, let them explain)

The key is to pause after mirroring. Most people will either elaborate (giving you more surface area) or acknowledge (giving you the opening to respond).

Labeling Emotions

What it is: Verbalizing the emotions you sense in the other person.

Why it works: When you put a name to someone’s emotions, it reduces defensiveness, builds trust, and makes people feel understood.

How to use it with your team:

• “It sounds like you’re frustrated with this project.”

• “It seems like there’s a lot of pressure on you right now.”

If you’re wrong, they’ll correct you. But this still gets them talking and helps you understand what’s really going on.

The Late-Night FM DJ Voice

What it is: Lowering your voice, slowing your pace, and keeping your tone calm – like a late-night radio DJ.

Why it works: It keeps conversations from escalating and helps you project confidence and control.

How to use it with your team:

• When giving tough feedback: “Here’s what I’m seeing. Let’s figure this out together.”

• When a team member is stressed: “I get that this is frustrating. Let’s walk through it.”

Be the one that sets the emotional tone. If you stay calm, others will follow.

Calibrated Questions

What it is: Asking open-ended “How” and “What” questions that make the other person feel in control.

Why it works: You steer the conversation without putting people on the defensive and encourage problem-solving instead of blame.

How to use it with your team:

• “Why didn’t this get done?” → “What’s the biggest challenge you’re facing here?”

• “Can you finish this by Friday?” → “How can we make sure this gets done by Friday?”

People are most likely to follow the script they write. The right questions let you act as their ghostwriter.

The “That’s Right” Moment

What it is: Summarizing what someone has said in a way that makes them say, “That’s right.”

Why it works: It signals deep understanding. Once someone feels truly heard, they become more open to your influence.

How to use it with your team:

• Team member: “I just feel like no matter how hard we work, we keep missing deadlines.”

• You: “So what I’m hearing is that you and the team are putting in a ton of effort, but roadblocks keep getting in the way.”

When they say, “That’s right,” you know you’ve built real trust.

Your 30-Day EQ Deployment Plan

Here's how to systematically implement these tactics in your next 30 days:

Week 1: Master Mirroring

• In your next 1:1s, mirror the last 3 words of important statements

• Note which team members elaborate vs. those who need follow-up questions

• Goal: Get 3 people to open up about challenges they haven't shared before

Week 2: Strategic Labeling

• Before tough conversations, write down 2-3 likely emotions in play

• Test your read: "Sounds like you're frustrated with [x]"

• Goal: Defuse 2 tense situations by naming the emotion first

Week 3: Calibrated Questions

• Replace every "Why" with "What" or "How"

• Start team discussions with: "What's making this hard?"

• Goal: Get your team to solve 3 problems without your direct input

Week 4: The "That's Right" Breakthrough

• In critical meetings, summarize key points until you hear "That's right"

• Make a mental note of what summaries worked vs. fell flat

• Goal: Turn 2 resistant team members into allies

Quick Wins to Start Today:

1. Replace "But" with "And" in your next difficult conversation

2. Count to 4 after someone finishes speaking (force yourself to pause)

3. Lower your voice when tension rises

4. Ask "What would make this work?" instead of pointing out problems

Red Flags You're Slipping:

• You're talking more than listening

• People get defensive in conversations with you

• Team members aren't bringing you problems early

• You're giving solutions instead of asking questions

Remember: EQ isn't about being nice.

It's about getting results through strategic influence.

Our goal is to build a community of 1 million thoughtful, curious leaders. Your reposts on any or all of the above are always appreciated.

Thank you for reading. We appreciate you!

Dave & Mar

What You Missed This Week

Did you miss last week’s MGMT Playbook?

📌 We shared a No-nonsense guide to thriving with remote teams in: How To Make Remote Teams Your Competitive Advantage

And here are our most popular posts last week:

1. How To Manage Your Boss

2. What Leaders Think Employees Want

3. 10 Signs You’ve Outgrown Traditional Leadership Advice

4. Brave Leaders Are Never Silent About Hard Things

5. 11 Signs You Might Be a Micromanager

6. 10 Bad Habit You need To Unlearn

Or why not check out today’s shares:

📌 7 Questions To Ask Before Taking a Job
📌 If They’re Not Earning Or Learning, They’re Leaving

Our goal is to build a community of 1 million thoughtful, curious leaders.

Your ♻️ reposts on any or all of the above are always appreciated.  

Thank you for reading. Appreciate you!

Dave & Mar

.